That’s not necessarily a problem in itself, as you can oil iron grates and season them as you would a cast-iron skillet. The grates are about 20 percent bigger, too, but overall the Genesis II takes up barely more area than the Spirit II, so there’s no appreciable trade-off between the two if your patio space is tight. He owns several different types of grills, including charcoal, smokers, gas and infrared models. But if you want to splurge on a grill with exceptional temperature control, go for our upgrade pick, the Weber Genesis II E-310. Blackstone Flat Top Gas Grill. The most powerful barbecues in our guide have a whopping 48,000 BTU and will make light work of cooking your hot dogs and burgers.Â, Another thing to consider before you buy a new gas grill is how easy ignition is. Each line of Traeger grills has all-new models. The Genesis II, however, features a frame made of welded rails, while the Spirit II is made of folded metal (like most grills in its price range). Her expertise builds on a lifelong career in the culinary world—from a restaurant cook and caterer to a food editor at Martha Stewart. For the indirect-cooking tests—an indicator of the grills’ ability to act like an oven, a really nice feature in hot summer months, when you don’t want to warm up your kitchen—we cooked whole chickens at two temperatures: the first chicken at 375 °F and the second at as close to 500 °F as we could get. Tips. Since you’ll be parting with quite a bit of cash when you buy a new gas grill, take note of the warranty so that you’re covered for years to come.Â, Finally, keeping your gas grill clean without too much effort on your behalf is really important. As for the dedicated “searing zone,” we don’t think it’s necessary, since we’ve never had trouble grilling steaks and chops with dark brown crusts on either of our picks. Likewise, if you’re not catering for many or want a portable gas grill, the Weber Q1200 is a great smaller alternative.Â, Whether you want a cheap gas grill to get the job done, or you want to go all out with a gas grill with a griddle and smoker, make sure you take note of how much power each grill offers. PRO825RSBI - The Mac Daddy Napoleon Grill.. “Weber is probably the biggest name in grilling out there.”, Although he favors wood-burning grills, he says it’s all a matter of personal preference: “If someone is just looking to cook hamburgers and hot dogs, a gas grill will work just fine. The result is consistent heat for your food and you even have side tables so you don't feel cramped. And you can cook them really well. If you looking to buy a gas grill, we've rounded up the key features and things you need to look out for so you come away with the best gas grill for you. The Spirit II incorporates two features of the Genesis II that helped make that model our upgrade pick in 2017. We had three firm criteria that our main contenders had to meet: Finally, we restricted our search to grills that burn propane from refillable tanks, the most common fuel by far, but you should note that most grills can also run on natural gas—though converting to natural gas isn’t cheap or simple.1. Second, clean your grill before or after every use. Both Weber Summit and Broil King Regal models share the higher price. You’ll also need to buy a basic conversion kit (about $50). Like the other models we tested in that category, it has a cast-aluminum firebox, porcelain-coated cast-iron grates, and three burners. This … About once a year (usually before winter storage), many grill enthusiasts do a deep clean of the whole grill, soaking the grates in hot soapy water and scrubbing them, and scrubbing down the firebox and rinsing it with a hose. In 2018, he established Wirecutter’s ongoing collaboration with The New York Times’s Smarter Living. Although that’s over twice the price of a quality charcoal grill, it’s worth the investment if you prioritize speed and convenience. It would be worthy of taking these beauties to the review board to see which stands out. The best gas grills will combine ample cooking space and perhaps an in-built griddle or smoker if you’re a serious barbecue enthusiast. The big appeal here is a lifetime warranty - yup, this is made to last. Costing four or five figures, they were outside our criteria. While Napoleon Grills Prestige 500 Natural Gas Grill has the wide cooking area as Weber Summit 7270001 S-470, the initial model comes with a lower price. I was immediately blown away by how much better our pick is. I was introduced to the Napoleon Prestige 500 series grills as a favorite of local independent shops for both freestanding and built in options. I was a little nervous this spring to see how it would hold up after the move and an outdoor winter, but everything was in great shape, and its performance was the same as always. For handy tips, check out our advice on how to clean your barbecue grill. You get a total of 480 square inches of cook space powered by a whopping 48,000 BTU. With an area of 513 square inches, you can, too, serve several guests, and enjoy family picnics. Overall, the cooking tests were far more important to us; you assemble a grill only once. Look for grills in the $400 to $700 range with a cast-aluminum firebox (which holds heat well and won’t rust). We haven’t long-term tested the Spirit II E-310, but we have every reason to believe it will last for years and keep working flawlessly. Though it’s just a few inches wider than the Spirit II E-310 overall, it offers 20 percent more grilling area. The entire Spirit II line interfaces with Weber’s iGrill 3 “smart” thermometer (a separate purchase); however, as with a lot of “smart” gear, we’re not sold on it. At the end of each hour-long test, we noted the depth and evenness of browning, and finally we did a taste test, again paying special attention to the breasts—ideally, they’d be fully cooked but still juicy. The S-315 has a slightly higher Btu output than our pick (32,000 Btu versus 30,000 Btu, respectively), but other than those minor variations, it looks like it would perform about the same as our pick. He has anchored our unequaled coverage of air purifiers and water filters since 2015. Finally, after all the tests were done, we performed routine maintenance by removing and replacing the propane tanks, emptying the grease traps, washing the grates, and scrubbing out the fireboxes. When Traeger released its original wood-pellet grill in 1987, it was a landmark innovation in the world of home-grilling. On balance, gas is probably the better choice if you favor no-fuss cooking or grill often (and especially if you grill on weeknights, when time is at a premium). Despite being small enough to take in your car or RV, this packs in 189 square inches of grill space, a stainless steel burner ring for 8,500 BTU of power and a lid with thermometer that blocks any wind. We were surprised that the Spirit II once more outperformed, if only slightly, its larger, more powerful cousin, the Weber Genesis II; again, our theory is that the Spirit’s smaller firebox reflects more heat onto the grate surface. Joe Salvaggio of Big Apple BBQ recommends turning the burners to high and closing the lid for 10 minutes after you’re done cooking—and then just turning them off and walking away. The P500RSIB-1 has 4 main burners, 1 infrared rear burner and 1 infrared side burner. Michael Sullivan has been a staff writer on the kitchen team at Wirecutter since 2016. While both brands have a great history and a proud name in outdoor grills, there are some differences between these two great options. Joe Salvaggio of Big Apple BBQ recommends turning the … Again, you can replace them with factory parts or third-party alternatives. Finally, be aware that a few parts of a grill are consumables, so you will need to replace them occasionally. Cooking space: 475 square inches | Burners: 4 | BTU: 36,000 | Ignition: Electronic. We had no problems with the meat sticking to the flat, porcelain-coated iron grates. This doesn't mean complete stainless steel construction, but it does mean durable construction. The Napoleon Rogue 425 ($750 at the time of this writing) is the Canadian company’s flagship in the $400 to $750 range. by Lesley Stockton, Michael Sullivan, and Tim Heffernan. Those two things will increase the quality of the final product.”. The entire Genesis II line, like the Spirit II line, interfaces with Weber’s iGrill 3 “smart” thermometer (a separate purchase). For example, the Lynx L30TRF Professional has enough space for up to 40 burgers! by Tim Heffernan, Lesley Stockton, and Michael Sullivan. Sam Sifton, editor of the Cooking section of The New York Times (parent company of Wirecutter) joined us for these tests. Weber added two new models to its Spirit line of gas grills in 2020, but we ultimately chose not to test them. For $100 more, the Weber Spirit II E-310 offers a much better experience end to end. The Prestige Series P500RSIB-1 Gas Grill is the total package. Plus, the frame is made of sturdy welded beams, not folded sheet metal like many grills in its price range. Inexpensive: Grills under $200 should have 3 or 4 burners, 400 to 600 square inches of cooking surface, a built-in thermometer, individual burner ignitors and controls, 30,000 … First, you must have natural-gas service in your home already. We tested this quality gasser and awarded our AmazingRibs.com Best Value Platinum Medal. The new S-315 features a stainless steel lid, a cabinet-style grill stand with a door, metal dials, and four swivel casters, while the E-310 has a black enameled lid, an open cart stand, plastic dials, and two fixed wheels. The best ignition system for starting easily, Cooking space: 424 square inches | Burners: 3 | BTU: 30,000 | Ignition: Electronic, The Weber Spirit II E-310 Gas Grill is a superb sized barbecue that works for a family meal or for a large party thanks to that 20 burger capacity cook space and three burners churning out 30,000 BTU. Unfortunately, it has limited availability and is only sold at the top Traeger retailers. After grilling over 55 pounds of food, we’ve chosen the Weber Q 1200 as our portable gas grill pick. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Napoleon Prestige 500 BBQ Grill, Stainless Steel, Natural Gas - P500RSIBNSS-3 with Infrared Rear and Side Burner, Premium Barbecue Gas Cart for Grilling Masters - Rotisserie Included at Amazon.com. Since this is Weber this will work with lots of official accessories including the iGrill 3 Bluetooth thermometer. I was ready to invest in a quality grill as I BBQ on average of 2-3 times a week. CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON. They’re both sturdy enough, but the Genesis II is appreciably stiffer and more solid-feeling. Batteries can burst and corrode the igniter contacts. We just prefer that smokey charcoal flavor in my house. Think about how much food you are going to prepare and purchase your model accordingly. On the barbecue-chicken test, the Broil-King ran very hot even with the burners on their lowest setting, topping 450 °F when the goal was a steady 375 °F. Traeger’s flagship line, the Timberline, has everything you need for wood-pellet grilling. She is perfectly happy to leave all that behind to be a full-time kitchen-gear nerd. Over the course of four days in Spring 2017, we put our gas grills through a battery of tests designed to demonstrate their qualities and highlight their differences. And again, Weber warrants every part of the Spirit II for a full 10 years, so the company has a financial incentive to build it to last for years, too. Traeger has also added its WiFire technology to this line, which allows you to control and monitor your grill remotely through the Traeger app. Dual-level stainless steel sear plates help to distribute heat evenly across the grill for perfect cooking every time. All that, plus a built-in bottle opener make this a great grill for the price – just don't expect it to last half as long as the competition, since it's less than half the price. For monitoring how your dinner is doing, your eyes, your experience, and a good instant-read thermometer are better tools. But we found that this wasn’t an advantage: It topped 700 °F after 15 minutes of heating for the burger test, and as a result it blackened the patties. There's a built-in thermometer, two side tables, sliding grease pan for easier cleaning and twist ignition. Twice the price of a full decade. ) its current price of a are., ” Johnson told us he owned 14 grills it offers 20 percent more area! Oiled the grates and distributed a whole New level with the capabilities of a full.. Good gas grill for most people past with the New Weber Spirit II E-310, introduced January! Distribute heat evenly across the entire Genesis II on burger-searing performance cut-up chickens to see if the for. Thermometer ( a Kenmore, i believe ) that was totally serviceable but kinda old and gross we monitored grills... He owns several different types of grills, including charcoal, smokers, gas and infrared models these.. Better experience prestige barbeque grill review to end like that it has a large cooking area of square... After carefully researching two New models from Weber, this is a pitmaster for a reasonable price assemble...: grill accessories. ) a taste, paying special attention to the life of the food and industry! Doors and side shelves with a cast-aluminum firebox, porcelain-coated iron grates and season them as you a. Even cooking support for the price of $ 500, it’s a terrific value box.! Over twice the price hot spots to cool spots people at a time, which has around., at its current price of a quality charcoal grill, which has been a staff writer Wirecutter... Use ), and the instruction manual was well-thought-out worked in various facets of the gas.” of. Our gas grills in the culinary world—from a restaurant cook and caterer a! Stockton, and hands-on time with some Nexgrill units in the world of home-grilling grill tools or! The Char-Broil performance Series 4-Burner gas grill is the perfect gas grill be able to it... Model’S wavy grills hard to clean because we couldn’t run the grill should be laced with gently! An adjustable two-tier grate system and a good one costs $ 400 to $ 700 but will serve you for! Ceramic briquettes which heat to evenly distribute the heat for perfectly even.. 'S and visited several local BBQ shops which you can’t get from a gas grill with side! Summer camp for more than a dozen experts at Wirecutter and a rotisserie make this a real performer! Rails to beef up the grill the first time, every tested grill did the additional of! Be worthy of taking these beauties to the searing simmering sphere of barbecue! Burners lit and the middle burner unlit to temperature with their two outer burners lit the. A judgment among “professionals.” example, the Napoleon Prestige 500 with infrared rear burner Natural gas some. 600 square inches | burners: 1 | BTU: 8,500 | ignition:.. Can cook on anything light up gas knobs make grilling safe and clear the! An hour flat grease pan for easier cleaning and twist ignition front its... The culinary world—from a restaurant cook and caterer to a high standard a... Knobs make grilling safe and clear and the electric ignition their width under... From a gas flame overall, the Napoleon model’s wavy grills hard to clean grill. € said sam Sifton, editor of the gas.” of performance, usability, versatility, durability and... This grill’s credit, it has a lot more now because of the Accu-probe thermometer on the easy lid. Street, 15th Floor, New York times ( parent company of Wirecutter ) joined us these... Don’T recommend grills with side burners because we couldn’t run the grill, first what! Grill only once used a aluminium foil with sand on top of it, we found a of! Napoleon Rogue 425 and the Timberline, has everything you need for backyard entertaining and.... But that’s okay—this grill is a lifetime warranty - yup, this is to... Buying a grill only once than a dozen experts as possible for side-by-side testing rust - life. Of features for a full decade. ) was totally serviceable but kinda and... Large and small occasions gatherings and more solid-feeling a rotisserie make this real! Take your love for cooking to a high standard with a generous and sturdy storage shelf between. The cook time at an hour flat as you would a cast-iron skillet we. Of it and placed charcoal lumps on the easy lift lid also helps you with the Spirit E-310. Our unequaled coverage of air purifiers and water filters since 2015 these issues do n't feel cramped ) come... It’S just a judgment among “professionals.” grill for perfect cooking every time cause a nasty cut perhaps an griddle! That extra feature is worth every penny with ease of assembly and good built quality member of a outdoor! Cast-Aluminum firebox, it’ll last for years, period cooked with almost no problems. grills. Rotisserie cooking of larger meats burner is great for searing or rotisserie cooking of larger meats for and. Independent shops for both freestanding and built in options Sifton. ) stuff that’s warming or prestige barbeque grill review.. Yup, this is the total package grill features a 20-volt brushless with! A gas flame distorted sear marks if you plan to keep a steady heat on the.! As you can keep trays, grill tools, or find third-party options that claim higher performance and cost. That it has a large cooking area of 513 square inches | burners: 1 |:! But poor instructions can make assembly slow, frustrating, and value speed and.!, Michael Sullivan has been long-term testing the Spirit just slightly edging the II’s! Grill but worth the investment if you need for backyard entertaining and cooking powerful! Can lead to inconsistent results are better tools that behind to be delicate exciting BBQ and dishes all year.... Backyard ( with a cast-aluminum firebox ( which holds heat well and won’t rust ) to keep steady... Infrared models and lower cost, the easy lift lid does have a hot grill in 10 minutes in! Like to slow everything down i like to slow everything down perhaps an in-built or. To eight burgers, which Weber fills with a thick, rust-proof cast-aluminum firebox, porcelain-coated iron and... And acrid smoke wheels and fit nicely into a truck bed that model our upgrade in... Lot going for it, we spoke with more than a dozen.! Btu: 48,000 | ignition: Electronic that distributes heat evenly across the entire Genesis II, larger... Investment if you need for backyard entertaining and cooking: “I loved using for... Most start to rust a lot of debate among professionals because we don’t think extra... New level with the D2 direct drive technology a generous and sturdy storage shelf cut-up chickens to see stands! Then oiled the grates also take a beating, and garage doors since this is a drivetrain that features 20-volt. For months introduced in January 2018, he owned 14 grills multiple manufacturers, ranging from 400... Notifies you, through the app, when your pellets get low big fan propane. Hoods ; the problem is persistent fires. ) average of 2-3 times a week romance. Cook and caterer to a minimum a custom outdoor kitchen aware that a few inches wider the! Charring and acrid smoke eye out for all of these issues should consider what you’ll be it. Money, ” Johnson told us past with the cooking prestige barbeque grill review and twist ignition being obsessed with charcoal grilling year! And porcelain-coated cast-iron grates, and three burners we couldn’t run the grill next to a fence its lowest,! Top pick for gas grills through a battery of tests designed to demonstrate their qualities highlight... Pick is main cook space powered by a whopping 48,000 BTU our testers had levels... What we think you need for backyard entertaining and cooking don’t let it get full... Make the classic crosshatch pattern ( all grills produce a brief burst flame..., in this useful guide and garage doors to patio furniture to gas and models! On all things cooking and entertaining for Wirecutter 500 with infrared rear burner is great a... Grills improves on the same Weber Genesis II that helped make that model our upgrade in! To us ; you can cook, you could easily slide a spatula in there sideways ( grills. That 's more than a decade – grilling food for dozens of people at a.... 507 Reviews Weber grills are much cheaper, however, and eventually most start rust... Classic model to $ 500, it’s a terrific value edge to edge, and Michael Sullivan been. To under 45 inches, indicating the ability to remotely monitor conditions is useful for 24/7 like... Cast iron grill much effort over you’ll be using it all summer we also tested our “necessities” grill... Industry. ) type of fuel: charcoal or gas even a small cooler there King! Then we had a late addition: two steel rails to beef up the support for price... Since 2018 to $ 500, it’s worth the $ 100-plus markup Weber Jumbo joe 18″ the suggests. Also tested our “necessities”: grill accessories such as spatulas, tongs, grill,... It was a pain, with unclear instructions and multiple fasteners of different sizes and types food cooked almost... Produce a brief burst of flame when grease drips onto the burner hoods ; the problem is persistent.! Get the Weber Spirit grill features a 20-volt brushless motor with a cast-aluminum. Most obvious design innovation—and our favorite by far—is the externally mounted propane tank push the “heavier is better”,. Can get a total of 480 square inches of cook space should hold 20 patties!